When arranging care for yourself or a loved one, one of the first decisions is whether to use a care provider or hire a private carer directly. At first glance, hiring privately may seem more flexible or cost-effective. However, there are important risks and responsibilities that are often underestimated.
At New Age Care, we want to help families make informed decisions and look beyond initial costs to consider safety, reliability, and peace of mind.
What Is a Private Carer?
A private carer is someone employed directly by an individual or family, rather than through a regulated care company. While this can offer more control, it also means taking on full responsibility for managing the arrangement.
Legal Responsibilities
Hiring a private carer usually means becoming their employer. This includes responsibility for:
- Contracts and employment rights
- Wages, tax, and National Insurance
- Holiday pay and sick pay
- Workplace pensions
- Employer’s liability insurance
Without experience in employment law, this can quickly become complex. Mistakes can lead to financial penalties or legal issues.
Safety and Background Checks
Ensuring the safety of a loved one is the highest priority.
Care providers carry out:
- Enhanced DBS checks
- Verified references
- Ongoing monitoring
When hiring privately, these checks are not guaranteed unless arranged independently. This increases the risk of unsuitable or unsafe individuals providing care.
Reliability of Care
Consistency is essential, particularly for ongoing care needs.
With a private carer, if they:
- Are unwell
- Take time off
- Leave unexpectedly
there is often no immediate backup. This can leave families needing to find alternative care at short notice.
Care providers offer continuity, with trained staff available to step in when needed.
Training and Standards
Professional care companies ensure carers receive regular training, including:
- Safe moving and handling
- Medication support
- Dementia care
- Safeguarding
Private carers may have experience, but there is no guarantee of up-to-date training or consistent standards unless independently checked.
Regulation and Accountability
Care providers in the UK are regulated and inspected, ensuring they meet defined standards of care.
This includes:
- Regular quality checks
- Clear procedures
- Formal complaints processes
Private arrangements do not have this level of oversight, which can make resolving issues more difficult if something goes wrong.
Insurance and Risk
When employing a private carer, you may be responsible for arranging appropriate insurance, including employer’s liability cover.
Without this, you could be financially liable if:
- The carer is injured while working
- An accident occurs in the home
Care providers manage this as part of their service, reducing risk for families.
The True Cost
While private care can appear more affordable initially, additional costs often arise, such as:
- Insurance
- Payroll services
- Training
- Cover for holidays or sickness
When these are factored in, the cost difference may be smaller than expected.
Peace of Mind
Perhaps the biggest difference is peace of mind.
Using a care provider offers:
- Thoroughly vetted carers
- Ongoing supervision and support
- Reliable cover
- A team available for guidance
This removes much of the pressure from families, allowing them to focus on their loved one rather than managing care.
Hiring a private carer can work in some situations, but it comes with significant responsibilities and potential risks. Understanding these fully is essential before making a decision.
For many families, using a professional care provider offers reassurance, structure, and consistency, ensuring care is safe, reliable, and well-supported.
At New Age Care, we are committed to delivering high-quality, person-centred care that supports both individuals and their families. If you would like to know more call about our care services visit www.newagecare.co.uk or calling us on 0808 808 5000.







